Project Name: East-West Highway Corridor Improvement Project

Country: Georgia

Project Number: P149952

The project implementing Agency: Roads Department of the Ministry of Regional Development and Infrastructure of Georgia

Bid/Contract Reference No: EWHCIP/CS/QCBS-03

Scope of Contract: DESIGN REVIEW AND SUPERVISION OF CONSTRUCTION WORKS FOR E-60 HIGHWAY CHUMATELETI-KHEVI SECTION (Approximate length of the section is 11.2 km)

Duration of Contract: 26 months (plus 24 months for Defects Liability Period) 

Method of Selection: Quality and Cost-Based Selection (QCBS)

Evaluation Currency: Georgian Lari   

Names of Shortlisted Consultant(s)/Firm that submitted proposals:

I. Name: JV composed of Soosung Engineering Co. Ltd/Korea (Leading Partner) and Dohwa Engineering Co. Ltd./Korea (member)

Technical Score: 72.03 (Specific Experience – 4.9; Methodology – 18.10; Key-Staff – 49.03)

Financial Proposal Price at the opening: 3,871,700.00 USD and 3,720,820.00 GEL;

Evaluated Price: 3,871,700.00 USD and 3,720,820.00 GEL;

Final Combined Evaluation Score: 77.62

Final Ranking: I

II. Name:  JV composed of Kocks Consult GmbH/Germany (Leading Partner) and Pyunghwa Engineering Consulting Ltd./ Korea (member)

Technical Score: 71.72 (Specific Experience – 4.55; Methodology – 17.20; Key-Staff – 49.97)

Financial Proposal Price at the opening: 3,301,150.00 USD and 5,254,680.00 GEL;

Evaluated Price: 3,301,162.00 USD and 5,254,680.00 GEL;

Final Combined Evaluation Score: 77.13

Final Ranking: II

III. Name:  JV composed of Rendel Limited/UK (Leading Partner) and Ingérop Conseil et Ingénierie/France (member)

Technical Score: 72.53 (Specific Experience – 3.90; Methodology – 17.70; Key-Staff – 50.93)

Financial Proposal Price at the opening: 2,542,150.00 EUR, 451,260.00 GBP, 470,000.00 USD and 6,082,700.00 GEL;

Evaluated Price: 2,542,150.00 EUR, 451,260.00 GBP, 470,000.00 USD and 6,082,700.00 GEL;

Final Combined Evaluation Score: 74.63

Final Ranking: III

IV. Name:  JV composed of Hill International NV/Netherlands (Leading Partner) and Egnatia Odos S.A/Greece (member)

Technical Score: 70.16 (Specific Experience – 3.75; Methodology – 18.10; Key-Staff – 48.31)

Financial Proposal Price at the opening: 3,450,700.00 USD and 7,006,730.83 GEL;

Evaluated Price: 3,450,700.00 USD and 7,006,732.60 GEL;

Final Combined Evaluation Score: 73.16

Final Ranking: IV

V. Name:  JV composed of Nievelt Ingenieru Gmbh /Austria (Leading Partner) and iC Consulten TZ GmbH/Austria (member)

Technical Score: 65.19 - Did not pass the minimum required technical score: 70 Points (Specific Experience – 3.75; Methodology – 18.30; Key-Staff – 43.14)

Financial Proposal Price at the opening: N/A;

Evaluated Price: N/A;

Final Combined Evaluation Score: N/A

Final Ranking: N/A

Awarded Consultant(s)/Firm:

Name:  JV composed of Soosung Engineering Co. Ltd/Korea (Leading Partner) and Dohwa Engineering Co. Ltd./Korea (member)

Technical Score: 72.03

Financial Proposal Price at the opening: 3,871,700.00 USD and 3,720,820.00 GEL;

Evaluated Price:

Final Combined Evaluation Score: 77.62

Final Ranking: I

Contract Price: 4,568,606.00 USD and 4,390,568.00 GEL (including taxes).