Project Name: East-West Highway Corridor Improvement Project
Loan No 8547-GE
Project No EWHCIP P149952
Contract N EWHCIP/CS/QCBS-02
Assignment Name: “Feasibility Study for the Creation of Logistics Centers for the Ministry of Economy and Sustainable Development of Georgia“
By and between
Ministry of Economy and Sustainable Development of Georgia and DORNIER CONSULTING INTERNATIONAL GMBH
Duration of the assignment is 6 months
Scope of the Project: The objective of this assignment is to conduct a feasibility study including market and gap analysis of logistics centers services, demand analysis and forecasts, identification of potential sites and their comparative analysis, preparation of detailed technical, economic and financial evaluations and environment and social impact assessment.
Evaluation Method: Quality and Cost Based Selection (QCBS)
Shortlisted Consultant:
No |
Short list of companies |
Country of origin |
1 |
JV TRN Ingenieria and TEIRLOG Ingenieria with sub-consultant Gzamshenproject Ltd. |
Spain/Spain/Georgia |
2 |
CPCS Transcom International Limited (CPSC) in association with UBI Consulting |
Canada/Uzbekistan |
3 |
JV IRD Engineering Srl and D'Appolonia S.P.A |
Italy/Italy |
4 |
Dornier Consulting International GmbH |
Germany |
5 |
DB International GmbH |
Germany |
6 |
TERA International Group Inc. |
USA |
5 consultants submitted technical and financial proposals:
1 |
JV TRN Ingenieria and TEIRLOG Ingenieria with sub-consultant Gzamshenproject Ltd. |
Spain/Spain/Georgia |
2 |
JV IRD Engineering Srl and D'Appolonia S.P.A |
Italy/Italy |
3 |
Dornier Consulting International GmbH |
Germany |
4 |
DB International GmbH |
Germany |
5 |
TERA International Group Inc. |
USA |
Technical Scores of Consultants
Read-out prices at Financial Proposal Opening
Consultant’s Name |
Financial Proposal |
Currency |
Consultant’s Attendance |
JV TRN Ingenieria and TEIRLOG Ingenieria with sub-consultant Gzamshenproject Ltd. (Spain) |
336,620 238,830 |
EUR GEL |
no |
DB International GmbH |
499,500 |
EUR |
no |
Dornier Consulting International GmbH |
285,576 38,440 |
EUR GEL |
Attended |
Evaluated prices:
Consultants’ კონსულტანტის სახელი |
Proposals’ prices წინადადების ფასი |
Evaluated price(s) შეფასებული ფასი |
Financial scores ფინანსური ქულა |
|
JV TRN Ingenieria and TEIRLOG Ingenieria with sub-consultant Gzamshenproject Ltd. (Spain) |
EUR GEL |
336,620 238,830 |
336,620 238,830 |
|
Dornier Consulting International GmbH (Germany) |
EUR GEL |
285,576 38,440 |
285,576 38,440 |
100 |
Combined Scores/შეჯამებული ქულები:
კონსულტანტის სახელი |
Technical Evaluation ტექნიკური შეფასება |
Financial Evaluation ფინანსური შეფასება |
Combined Evaluation შემაჯამებელი შეფასება |
||||
Technical |
Weighted |
|
Financial |
Weighted |
|
|
|
JV TRN Ingenieria and TEIRLOG Ingenieria with sub-consultant Gzamshenproject Ltd. (Spain) |
84.23 |
67.38 |
II |
70.75 |
14.15 |
81.53 |
II |
Dornier Consulting International GmbH |
80.35 |
64.28 |
I |
100 |
20 |
84.28 |
I |
Award recommendation |
To highest combined technical/financial score. |
Successful Consultant/გამარჯვებული კონსულტანტი:
Dornier Consulting International GmbH (Germany)
Contract Signing Date September 16,2016
Contract Amount: EUR 285,576 and GEL 38,440 without taxes